8 responses

  1. Gary S
    November 21, 2017

    Thanks for this article, as there isn’t much written on SDB. I’d be very interested in learning the rules on the AH vs A rules in SDB!

    Reply

  2. Al on the Net
    November 21, 2017

    Something is not clear. For the question “Is the flush penalty to the “JT” a 2-6 and the fifth card suited with the A?” there are 2 different actions for “If no”. What gives.

    Reply

    • Bob Dancer
      November 21, 2017

      Is the flush penalty to the “JT” a 2-6 and the fifth card suited with the A?
      If yes, is it an 8 or 9?
      If yes, play AJ — end
      If no, play “JT” — end
      If no, continue

      One of the problems is that the indention I used in my original Word document didn’t translate clearly when it was posted here.

      What I intended is that the first “if no” relates to the fifth card being suited with the A while not being an 8 or 9 — such as A♠ J♥ T♥ 7♠ 6♥

      The second “if no, continue” was intended to be the case where the fifth card was not suited with the A — such as A♠ J♥ T♥ 7♣ 5♥ or maybe A♠ J♥ T♥ 8♣ 5♥. Those cases have their own rules, which are covered below the rule you mention.

      The flow chart works well for me. Sometimes “someone else’s” flow chart doesn’t work that well for me — and I know from experience that my way of looking at things isn’t always clear to others.

      What I suggest is you make your own chart in a way that works for you. There are a lot of software products out there you can use. Simply start with A♠ J♥ T♥ and vary the other two cards. There really aren’t that many combinations. If you can find a way that makes more sense to you, use it!

      Reply

  3. Kevin Lewis
    November 21, 2017

    Can you quantify the benefit from consistently employing the flow chart? How often does the situation come up? What would be the loss from simply holding the JT all the time–or the A all the time? What is the gain per hour by playing this particular hand perfectly?

    I think all of us who don’t have a massive cerebral memory bank might want to know how often these arcane situations come up before we devote any effort to memorizing them. Also, presuming we are playing with an advantage–and without naming the place or situation, I know of at least one play involving this specific game that returns 101.1%–would conforming to this or any other specific rule slow us down enough that we’d get in fewer hands, thus diluting the small incremental gain from playing perfectly?

    A similar discussion would be considering penalty cards at FPDW. Not doing so knocks you down from 100.76% (perfect play) to about 100.71%. Yet, you might get in 50 more hands an hour by playing “almost perfect” strategy. It’s a bit condescending to say that reluctance to learn the arcane ramifications of a particular hand in a particular game requires more concentration and study than some persons “wish to endure.” They may simply not see the benefit in expending the effort as well as the time, so little of which is allotted to us on this mortal orb, to do so. Most of us regard the various esoteric permutations of VP strategy as at most, a means to an end, not an intrinsically enjoyable or time-worthy subject of study.

    Reply

  4. 99% Dancer fan
    November 22, 2017

    Nice read Bob!

    Reply

  5. Casino Archives
    December 4, 2017

    Thanks for posting this detailed flowchart! For beginners, To play, you start by choosing how many coins you want to bet.

    Reply

  6. Carcounter
    December 21, 2017

    Nice to see an article on 9/5 SDB, which is the best game available where I play. I don’t crush my brain to avoid a minor mistake, but I got 8 of the questions right, pretty quickly. Good for my confidence.

    Reply

  7. Charles cariello
    June 11, 2024

    I don’t understand why the Jack ten suited in this game is rated so high and why would you ever hold AJ un suited..?

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top
mobile desktop