• Home
  • Archived Blogs
    • James Grosjean (AP)
      • About James Grosjean
      • View all posts
    • Bob Dancer (Video Poker)
      • About Bob Dancer
      • View all posts
      • Video Poker Classes
    • Richard Munchkin (AP)
      • About Richard Munchkin
      • View all posts
    • Lou Antonius
      • About Dr. Lou Antonius
      • View all posts
    • Blair Rodman (Poker)
      • About Blair Rodman
      • View all posts
    • FrankB (Sports)
      • About FrankB
      • View all posts
    • Jack Andrews (Sports)
      • About Jack Andrews
      • View all posts
    • Jimmy Jazz (AP)
      • View all posts
    • Anthony Curtis
      • About Anthony Curtis
      • View all posts
    • Guest Bloggers
    • Podcast
  • The Games
    • Bingo Rooms
    • Blackjack
    • Keno Rooms
    • Poker Rooms
    • Video Poker
      • Best Video Poker
      • Bob Dancer Articles
      • Game Room
    • Sports Betting Books
  • Shop
    • Blackjack Strategy
    • Casino Comps & Promotions
    • Casino-Game Strategy Cards
    • Game Protection
    • James Grosjean Strategy Cards (ShopLVA Exclusive)
    • GWAE-Author Products
    • Las Vegas Advisor Membership + Member Rewards
    • Poker-Strategy
    • Sports Betting & Daily Fantasy
    • Tournament Play
    • Video Poker Strategy
  • Arnold Snyder’s Blackjack Forum Online
  • LVA Home
  • Home
  • Video Poker
  • Money Management Rules Are Largely Worthless

Money Management Rules Are Largely Worthless

May 27, 2014 Leave a Comment Written by Bob Dancer

Video poker is the only game at which I gamble. Although I moved to Vegas more than twenty years ago to count cards at blackjack and used to play both bridge and backgammon for money, today it’s video poker exclusively for me. But I still read publications devoted to other games. Occasionally I’ll read something by someone writing about another game that will give me insight into how I can improve my video poker play. Poker magazines, especially the free ones given out in poker rooms, are part of my library.

Not too long ago I was reading one of these poker magazines and saw an article about money management. The author shared his “secret:” If you get ahead, put a certain number of chips to the side as your profit. You will go home a winner if you have the discipline to never dip into those “profit” chips. While this is a true enough statement if you are only going to gamble once during your lifetime, it is actually harmful advice if you plan to gamble regularly.

Let’s change the game to video poker and see why it is so harmful. Let’s assume you started with $100 and built it up to $300 and made the “money management decision” that if it ever got down to $200 again you would quit and go home with $100 profit. What could possibly be harmful about that?

What is harmful is that you are not considering the conditions under which you are playing. Is this a game where you are the favorite? (If not, why are you playing anyway?) Is there a special promotion going on (i.e. double points or some special award for certain 4-of-a-kinds)? Are you feeling alert? Are you enjoying yourself? Is this is a better-than-average play for you?

These are all important considerations. Tonight’s score is just one small data point on your year-long result log. And this log will show many sessions where you win and many where you lose. The best technique to have more and bigger winning sessions is to play more when you have the biggest advantage. So if double points last for three more hours and you are feeling great, then this is a probably a good situation for you to continue playing. But if your score drops down to $200 and your money management rule says to stop, then your money management rule is costing you money. Or if double points end, you should probably quit even though you have won big over the last half hour. Deciding about whether to play based on game conditions is important. Making this decision based on what has happened since you last went to bed is not.

Many people care a lot about whether they are up or down for the day. I don’t. I don’t think today’s score matters much at all. My score for the last year? Yes, that matters a lot. If that’s not positive I am doing something very wrong. But my score over the last two hours? Totally irrelevant. So any sort of shenanigans to play more or less just because you are a little up or down on the day is useless and probably counter-productive.

I recently re-read another money management rule that makes a lot of sense for most players. Simplistic, to be sure, but useful for many of us. It was from Michael Shackleford, the self-proclaimed Wizard of Odds (www.wizardofodds.com). Shackleford’s rule is to stop playing when it isn’t fun anymore. Period. That’s his whole rule. For recreational players, this makes a lot of sense. For professional players, whether you are having fun or not isn’t a high priority — although even professional players tend to play better when they are enjoying themselves.

If I were no longer enjoying what I do, I’d retire. I’m certainly old enough. If I could no longer come out ahead at the end of most years, I’d retire. Probably both conditions will happen at about the same time. If I can’t win anymore, it won’t be nearly so much fun, and I will be gone!

My radio show co-host, Richard Munchkin, uses the amount he’s ahead as a stopping point all the time. And for him that makes sense! He’s playing table games (usually with a much bigger advantage than we find at video poker) and he has to decide how much the casino will let him win before they do something about the game or do something about his welcome. In that situation, it makes a lot of sense to have a rule for a particular casino that says something like, “When I get ahead $20,000, I’ll quit for the day.” At other casinos, his rule will be different.

For video poker the dynamics are different. Generally speaking we lose, lose, lose until we hit a royal flush (or perhaps four aces or deuces). The “all at once a big score” feature doesn’t lend itself to incremental stopping points. Whether we are up or down $500 (or any other figure) tells us nothing about whether we will hit a royal flush later in the day.

Facebooktwitteryoutubeinstagram
Video Poker
Podcast – guest Andy Bloch #3
Podcast – guest Eric Raskin author of The Moneymaker Effect

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Join LVAs Mailing List


Sign me up for:

GWAE Post Categories

  • Advantage Play (653)
    • Advanced Strategy (262)
    • Advice for Players (258)
    • Comps & Promos (75)
    • Game Protection (10)
  • Breaking News (8)
    • News Stories (3)
  • Casino Games (395)
    • Blackjack (31)
    • Craps (11)
    • Other Table Games (13)
    • Poker (33)
    • Slot Machines (5)
    • Video Poker (302)
  • Daily Fantasy Sports (2)
  • Gambling Glossary & Terminology (19)
  • Gambling Online (7)
  • General Thoughts/Opinion (78)
  • GWAE Podcast Episodes (643)
  • Non-Casino Games (3)
  • Reviews: Books, Movies, TV (29)
  • Sports betting (46)
  • Tournaments (2)

Recent Comments

  • coconut on What Would You Do?
  • KOAficionado on Colin Jones (S1 E9): Knockout KISS
  • A McGill on New Blackjack, Same Old Baloney
  • 바카라사이트 on The Cheating Game
  • Bajilive on “You’ve Already Hit the Royal”

Recent Posts

  • Business credit cards for profession gamblers and APs
  • Podcast – Sherriff AP episode 9
  • Spinach!
  • THE IMPORTANCE OF EVALUATING YOUR RESULTS IN BLACKJACK
  • Billy’s Book
Never miss another post

GWAE Bloggers

  • About Andy Uyal
  • About Anthony Curtis
  • About Bill Ordine
  • About Blair Rodman
  • About Bob Dancer
  • About FrankB
  • About Jack Andrews
  • About James Grosjean
  • About Nicholas Colon
  • About Richard Munchkin
  • Bloggers
  • Play Desert Diamond
  • Podcast – attorney Bob Nersesian 12/8/22
  • Podcast – Mickey Crimm 3/23/2023
  • SuperBlog
“Gambling With An Edge” is a unique cyber-hub where some of most-respected minds in professional gambling collectively share their expertise, advanced-strategy tips, insights, and opinions via the GWAE “SuperBlog” and weekly GWAE radio show.
The expertise to be found here spans the full spectrum of casino games, advantage-play techniques, and legal-wagering opportunities in the U.S., with contributors including James Grosjean (AP, table games), Bob Dancer (video poker), Richard Munchkin (AP, author), Blair Rodman (poker), Frank B. (sports betting), and others.

Other LVA Blogs

Frugal Vegas with Jean Scott
LVA Travel
Stiffs & Georges with David McKee
Vegas with an Edge
Powered by LasVegasAdvisor.com copyright 1983-2018 Huntington Press | All Rights Reserved | Privacy Policy