Tim,
I just returned from my annual Florida excursion where I took in ten games in eight different camps. Furthermore, my ex-partner, as usual as he lives in Arizona, has been to a half dozen Cactus games. We have a pretty good feel for which teams are for real and which have/will have problems.
Where as you tear apart each team's schedule, I tend to look at each team's division strength plus factor in each team's feel at the spring camps. I must admit I love your analysis of both the Giants and the Phils and agree with your final assessment but got there differently.
My comments on your team wins (btw - I never make these plays, not my thing:
- Giants Over: 87.5 is ridiculously low, what are "they" thinking? Not only will they surpass that number, they will repeat. As previously stated, they are a year more experienced and so deep that they can and will absorb the impact of any potential injuries. I have to retract a previous statement. This division is not that strong at all. I'm afraid of the Rockies because of their depth and believe the "new look" Padres will give teams fits. As for the D'backs and Dodgers, they are all over the place and trying to find themselves. Donnie Baseball will cost them W's and Zona has yet to impress. Bottom line, Giants will coast in a mediocre division.
- Phillies Under: had dinner with a couple of Philadelphia reporters and they tell me Phillie management has concerns. Their lineup has aged and the loss of Jason Werth is a killer. With the exception of Doc, the starters have a history of periods of stays on the DL and/or periods of fades. And, as you mention, there are now serious relief concerns. Finally, the NL East division will be real tough (see notes below). The Phillies will knock on the door but 97.5 wins, c'mon!
- Arizona Over: the number is low but not enough there to get me excited.
- Angels Under: agree because they are a mess.
- Houston Over (as addressed in another thread): despite a messy spring so far, I still think they will get to 73 somehow.
Additional notes based on who/what I saw:
- Impressed with (Grapefruit only) - Braves, Mets, Tigers, and Wash. Yankees (playing very loose) and Red Sox are showing much early swagger. Stating the obvious, both need to stay healthy.
- Not impressed with: Twins, O's, Rays and Marlins
- Lastly, Blue Jays might surprise some folks. More on that another time.
BASBALL FEVER - CATCH IT!
Rudy