Looks like Sue was first by a whisker, but I really like the songs that Sue and Tony nominated, so I'm just going to go ahead and name them both.
Sue did I Walk The Line, by Johnny Cash, and Tony did Good Luck Charm, by Elvis. Great songs, guys!
OK, in 1961, a group from Pittsburgh breathed new life into an old 1930s standard by recording a doo-wop version that shot to the top of the charts in the US and UK:
And then there suddenly appeared before me
The only one my arms will ever hold