Originally posted by: Jerry Ice 33
Whoa whoa whoa......why can't the person itemize again if his itemized deductions are greater than the standard deduction?
He can. But if you examine the sea change from prior years to TY 2018 and beyond, it's now very rare that itemized deductions exceed the standard deduction, because a) the standard deduction is larger, and b) itemized deductions have been virtually eliminated.
This was touted as a wonderful thing. But at best, it was a shell game, because tax rates on income over the standard deduction (or, over the total of itemized deductions) were sharply increased. Dig up a 2019 1040 tax table and compare it to prior years if you don't believe me. AND...the Trumpy shell game decreed that those rates would go up every year through 2025.
The net effect was an overall increase in tax rates of about 2% for the average taxpayer. But the people who were really fucked were those who would have wanted to itemize before. Those consisted primarily of two groups: those who had suffered one-time large, unusual losses (like uninsured medical or disaster losses), and those who had large mortgage interest expenses (recurring). One could EASILY pay far more in interest expenses than the standard deduction would compensate for. Thus, if one couldn't itemize, and one paid substantial mortgage interest, the doubling of the standard deduction wouldn't have come close to making up for it. And as I've said before, homeowners in blue states and cities were most affected by this--so of course, the Trump team didn't give a shit (or maybe they cackled to themselves about sticking it to them LIBBURULS).
Itemized deductions were created to recognize the fact that someone whose house burns down or who breaks a leg has functionally less income than someone who earns the same amount but has nothing untoward happen. They were also created to encourage home ownership and make it easier to attain.
I can only laugh ruefully at the RepubliQ efforts to stamp out that iconic aspect of traditional AMURRICAN values--home ownership. Two kids, a puppy dog, and a white picket fence. Oh, wait, not any more--corporate profits must take precedence!