Originally posted by: Jerry Ice 33
What did you actually write in the letter, Kevin? Are you saying you owed but you filed and didn't pay?
I've thought about doing this myself many times. Something to the effect of "I don't like the way you spend my income tax dollars so you can keep what I've had withheld on my W-2 but that is it." :) But then I'm just afraid they will send me a nasty IRS letter with a penalty and interest tacked on.
Here's the thing. The penalties are actually much more severe for not filing (if your income is above the taxable threshhold) than for owing them money. I wouldn't be the only person filing but not paying--not by a damn sight. Most folks have already paid up and are in fact owed refunds, so they have every reason to file. But I claimed total exemption from withholding, and most of my income for 2025 was not from work, anyway.
So what they'll do is, sometime in August, they'll send a letter: "WELL?" and tell me I'm subject to a 10% penalty. Then, in November, when they send out the nastygrams to everybody they think owes them money, I'll get one, too. Big deal. I'd be something like two millionth in line. And realistically? They focus their collection efforts on younger (because it's a bitch to file a claim against an estate) and wealthier (obviously) scofflaws than I.
And I did explicitly say in my letter that I paid the government an unjust tax in 2025 and that tax had been declared unlawful...so THEY owed ME money. I doubt I'll ever get a response from a human, but I actually do feel I had an obligation to say why I wasn't paying.