As Smokey once said, "I second that emotion!" Is it fair or unfair? I don't know. A sudden gust of wind can turn a good shot into a loser, but can't that be said about a lot of holes on tour? Some say it's not a bad hole, it just shouldn't be #17. On the other hand, it's made for some interesting finishes. It's also one of the few holes on tour that immediately connect you with that course. All I know is that it makes for some great Sunday afternoon viewing.
Good Luck!
Ric at Joes