I am a Diamond at TR and Platinum MLife.I have been for Diamond 8 years and Platinum MLife since they started the system.
I play Craps and Blackjack.
For years I only played at Ceasars,Rio,Paris,Ballys
I switched to MGM properties several years ago in Las Vegas for a couple reasons
1. My play was not comped at TR properties on the same level as MGM properties.
2.MGM has nicer properties and better entertainment options in Las Vegas.
When looking for comps,all casinos base it on a % of your theo.
What you get depends on your play and the property.
$25 hand for 4 hours may get you a free room at Harrahs (TR) or Excalibur(MLife)
It won't get you a free lunch at Caesars or Bellagio.
My experience has been that MLife comps table play better and I can sight many examples of comparable play.
I know MLife made changes in Oct that reduced slot comps and limited the machines that you earn full tier credits on.Since I don't play machines I am not sure how that stacks up against TR earning.
In terms of Bellagio or anyone else rating play,keep in mind,comps are base on a % of theo.
So rating $10/hand blackjack may not mean a thing in terms of getting anything back.
Finally,don't go by the MLife website for what you can actually get staying at one of their properties.
Call the hotel and get a host or MLife representative they will usually offer more than their pathetic online offers.
The MLife website gives me 3 comp nights in a regular room at Aria or Bellagio.
My host at Aria gives me 5 nights in a Sky Suite.
This is where TR does have it over MLife as the TR website tells you what you get and you can book it online.
I don't want to stay at any of their Las Vegas properties but their system is better.