Please rank your MLife casino buffets that are available on Myvegas.

We have eaten evening buffets at 4 of the M-Life properties, .... Bellagio, Mirage, Mandalay Bay, and Luxor.

I would rate them in the following order (but please remember this is only my personal opinion)

1. Luxor (a pleasent surprise, nice steamed clams, halved crab legs, not hectic and a nice atmosphere)
2. Mirage (nice desert area, warm Macaroon Cookies, etc)
3. Mandalay Bay (not bad, but not great .... I think it was $1 more than Luxor)
4. Bellagio (a disappointment [evening & breakfast] very crowded, too hectic/noisy, and not great service)

Rick

EDITED TO ADD: The Luxor had a self-serve drink area for both hot and cold drinks, which was nice.

Self-professed anti-buffet person. Generally overpriced for mediocre food at best--bland, uninspired. JMO.
But due to some free offers I have tried several over the last year.
Cosmo Wicked Spoon very very good
Bacchanal at Caesars very very good
Paris very good (a little less inventive than the other 2 but very flavorful with lots of choices)
PH Spice Market--tried it 2x. Unimpressed both times. Peeled shrimp & split cold crab legs were the only thing memorable.
That being said I would not eat at any of these places for more than half the price than they are charging. For $100 DH & I can have a really great meal elsewhere.
We will probably be trying Mirage, Aria & Bellagio free due to MyVegas this month (yes, the free ones cost more coins than the BOGO, but those are FREE & we have coins to spend) Those seem to be the 3 that get the highest ratings of the MyVegas choices plus we are at Caesars so Mirage & Bellagio are very convenient; we play poker at Aria so that is convenient and we arrive on a Sunday, and Mirage is the only one of these 3 we can use on a Sunday. DH isn't thrilled about 3 buffets, but even he agreed that free is good, even for a decent buffet. We will probably eat protein bars in the rooms for breakfast then do buffets for lunch, and light dinner. Free is good--though I have had buffets that weren't worth free...

I just went to Circuss Circus for breakfast and it was good. Pretty basic but everything was decent. really large with plenty of choices. I wouldn't pay $16 for it but for free from MyVegas it's a steal. the ham and omelets were really good. Stay away from the mac and cheese too salty. I'm going to try dinner there next time.

Bellagio is fantastic, Aria good, Mirage good, MGM average, Mandalay Bay average,

Tier 1 - Bellagio/Aria
Tier 2 - Mirage/Mandalay
Tier 3 - MGM/Luxor
Tier 4 - Excalibur/Circus Circus

This is based on everything being free.

I agree with most of the above: Bellagio and Aria are the top.
I don't think any of the others are worth eating at even for free (except for breakfast, which is hard to ruin).
As a group, we've comp'd a lot to Mirage (dinners), and I find it mediocre with poor selection. If I wasn't with a group, I wouldn't eat there with a comp.

To give you an idea bout my preferences, I'm mostly with kbunde, that buffets are not a great choice for dining.