I will agree with both sides. No affiliation with the guy whatsoever, but I will reveal one of my best kept secrets. One of the very few opinions I put a ton of stock in is a guy by the name of Chuck Oliver. He played at Auburn, does a radio show in Atlanta.
He also does some Conference USA color commentary on Sports South or Comcast regional or something. He goes to a lot of the practices. His ATS picks in college football are as good as any IMHO.
But in my own handicapping, I also use Scouts Inc, Ron Jaworski's game film notes, etc. In a sense, touts can now somewhat legitimately claim they have "scouts" working for them. It's well worth the ESPN Insider fee.
Greg Cosell's film room notes, though a lot of fluff and obvious, have also proven valueable.
So it's more than just numbers, but I will take all of the above.