I don't follow the Redskins, but hard to believe that Grossman gives your team a better chance to win than McNabb. Living in Chicago, I know we were happy to see the Bears pull Grossman and start playing Orton. Of course, that didn't last too long either. When you see all these teams playing musical chairs with the QB position, you have to admire what guys like Favre, Brady, Manning, and a couple others have done. McNabb might be finished, but I wouldn't label him a POS like Fat Albert - IMO.
Will McNabb get any HOF consideration? Probably not, but if one of those Philly teams HAD gone all the way, he might have. Kurt Warner likely gets in, but not without that ring. Kind of like Ron Santo. If you don't win something, you don't get the consideration.