Is This a Weird Gift Idea?

The great thing about LVA is the mix of people from all walks of life conveniently gathered in one place. Hopefully you'll take a moment of your time to tell me what you think of this gift idea.

About ten years ago my husband went to Ireland to visit his mom and her new husband who was there working for a year. During the visit they gave him a gift of a bottle of Green Spot Whiskey. As they usually do with gifts, they made a big deal about how expensive it was and what a great gift they were giving him. So, my husband brings it home and sticks it in the cabinet. I don't know if there is a proper way to store whiskey but it has been upright in our kitchen cabinet along with baggies, plastic wrap,etc. for the past ten years. This weekend they are having an anniversary party. I asked my husband what his plans were for a gift. He told me that he's giving the whiskey back to them because now that it's ten years older its even better and they'll love it. I don't think it's a good idea. My opinion is that if they gave him the whiskey it was because they expected him to enjoy it not store it for ten years and then re-gift it back to them. If it were me I think I'd be insulted. Does the whiskey really get better with age when it's already been bottled? The other weird thing is that I've never seen anyone in his family drink whiskey. I kind of wonder if they re-gifted it to my husband in the first place. If that's the case, then my husband's idea is really terrible. So far, the only person I asked thought it was kind of a strange idea. What do you think?
Trust your gut on this one. He needs to give them something from his/your heart, not theirs. If they like booze, plenty of authentic American options are available, from a stellar bourbon to a chart-topping California wine.
Thanks Ken. A bottle of wine is much more their style. My gift to them is that I'm not going to their party.
I agree with not re-gifting back to them but WOW did you google it. It is quite the prestigious whiskey, if you enjoy whiskey. Depending on the year etc it ranges from 35 to 700 Euros (at least I think that is the currency)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Green_Spot_%28whiskey%29

I would be kind of taken aback if someone regifted something like that. I might even be a little insulted. I know I would be speechless for sure upon receipt of it. Have to admit I was a little speechless at the question.
I'm sure Miss Manners would say absolutely not and I would agree.

JOHN
Let me be clear, I was against it from the start. I would have loved to have the bottle out of my cabinet years ago. I just need some written proof for my husband about what the average person would think.
Quote

My gift to them is that I'm not going to their party.


I would not re-gift it.
FYI it does not improve over time in the bottle.
Green spot is a fairly good Irish Whiskey - not super expensive - 45 Euros
Green spot single pot still 10 year and 12 year are expensive Irish whiskies - 250 - 300 Euros.


For whiskey to be proprely aged doesn't it have to be in the correct kind of barrels like cherry or oak? I don't think a bottle cuts it.
Yes.
Already a LVA subscriber?
To continue reading, choose an option below:
Diamond Membership
$3 per month
Unlimited access to LVA website
Exclusive subscriber-only content
Limited Member Rewards Online
Join Now
or
Platinum Membership
$50 per year
Unlimited access to LVA website
Exclusive subscriber-only content
Exclusive Member Rewards Book
Join Now