Mare, please repeat your question. Im sorry, I missed it amidst all the squabbles. But please read on, because I do address your other points.
alanleroy, I would think that if you are indeed giving the casinos plenty of "action" that they wouldnt complain. But I can't speak for the casinos. I do know that they frown on the practice. Earlier in this thread I told you about someone I know from the Miami area who literally dumped tens of thousands of dollars in one weekend in Vegas while hopping from the Golden Nugget to the Venetian and then to Caesars, picking up free play and air fare reimbursement from two hotels for the same trip. What I neglected to say was that six months later this high roller was totally cut off, even though in one weekend she lost more than $75-thousand that she will admit to losing. Heck, she might have lost more.
Mare, right now I have a standing offer from three different casinos for "show up money" in Vegas. to qualify for the "show up money" I have to do two things: 1-- re-open a credit line and 2-- check into the hotel. I literally could show up, sign the credit line, take their free money and head off to another casino. But I won't do that. Ive gambled at all three casinos before -- and they want me to come back after a hiatus of more than 4 years.
And there are two reasons why I won't: 1. I dont think its "right." 2. I can just as easily SAVE these offers for the future, when I might want to actually stay at one of these casinos -- why blow the offer when I don't need it?
Frankly, I think this concept of "hotel hopping" to collect free play is -- from the players point of view -- short sighted. But, as Ive said before, if you are giving the casinos THAT MUCH action then go for it and have a great time. If you are not giving the casino the expected "action" you will lose this perk and the loss might come when you actually need it.
And Mare, do I put "all my eggs in one basket" ? Pretty much, yes. For casinos in Vegas I stay at Caesars. Here in SoCal I stopped going to Pechanga and now play VP at Rincon. When I play live poker Ive pretty much stopped going to Commerce and Hollywood Park and now almost always play exclusively at The Bike. those are the casinos I prefer and thats where I maximize my comps by concentrating my play. (The Bike does have a comp system for cash games, and they give free food 24/7 in the high limit area-- great steaks, sushi and Asian foods with names I cannot pronounce.