Quote
Originally posted by: MoneyLA
Billybuckeye please explain how Frank meeting with Singer would bias Frank's evaluation? It seems to me that any investigator would want to be able to do a thorough inquiry and it has been noted that some of Singer's system has never been made public. Let Frank may his fair and complete analysis and report. If he didn't give Singer a chance then the report would be biased.
Frank might indeed find in his analysis exactly what you want to hear. But if there are any doubts about his investigation the issues will never be resolved
Frank is doing his job well and I commend him for how he has rejected some of Singer's critics for their unfair bias.
Let him do his job. Then let him report. Then comment. It's only fair. And what is unfair is that RS will not be able to respond directly here. Fortunately for ALL sides there are other venues where Rob is not censored.
Originally posted by: MoneyLA
Billybuckeye please explain how Frank meeting with Singer would bias Frank's evaluation? It seems to me that any investigator would want to be able to do a thorough inquiry and it has been noted that some of Singer's system has never been made public. Let Frank may his fair and complete analysis and report. If he didn't give Singer a chance then the report would be biased.
Frank might indeed find in his analysis exactly what you want to hear. But if there are any doubts about his investigation the issues will never be resolved
Frank is doing his job well and I commend him for how he has rejected some of Singer's critics for their unfair bias.
Let him do his job. Then let him report. Then comment. It's only fair. And what is unfair is that RS will not be able to respond directly here. Fortunately for ALL sides there are other venues where Rob is not censored.
1. I hope/trust Frank's dissertation will be interesting and informative but it won't resolve any doubts.
2. Frank has not rejected any critics' arguments.
3. Frank's examples of basic probability meet with arguments and disagreement. Singer's system is a bit more complicated and Frank's evaluation won't convince anyone or change their minds if their minds are already made up.
