Quote
Originally posted by: mrmarcus12LVA
Originally posted by: mrmarcus12LVA
QuoteDoes their answer change when they say "Abracadabra," instead?
Originally posted by: FrankKneeland MATH NERDS... Let's say mothers name their female offspring Florida with probability p (where p is quite small).
I'd love to respond to this, but I don't know what you are trying to say. I'll try to cover the bases.
I am not good enough or qualified enough at math to comment on or dispute what the MATH NERDS website said on this. (They consists of mostly math professors).
If you are absolutely sure there is an error in their use and or application of Bayes' Theorem you really should take action. This is how it's being taught in our schools and text books. If there is an error you should bring it to their attention immediately.
I could find no fault in either their math, or the answers to the Two Girls Problem out of the book The Drunkards Walk. That doesn't mean there isn't one. I simply can't understand your objections, assuming you still have them.
Not really sure what the "Abracadabra" comment really meant. It would be easier if when making serious comments you did not use a metaphor. I know only one thing for sure. There is little point to us arguing over other people's words and ideas. You should take it up with the sources. Here I was but a messenger and not one qualified to comment on the contents of what I have carried. I ran the 26 miles to Marathon, told you the Athenians won, now it's time to die.