I've been a member since the beginning, since the LVA get together at "Boomtown," since sports comps were as good as race comps, since vp comps were as good as slot comps.
Original value was in the newsletter, which pointed out values one couldn't find in a non-internet world. The original value in LVA.com, the paid side, was that many serious, knowledgeable actual gamblers posted who knew how to count cards, knew comp in-and-outs, knew stuff in general. They left -- pearls before swine and all that. AC insulted some of the posters, and they were gone. Some guys were off-the-wall and abrasive, but they knew their stuff. Gone.
A lot of things happened in the interim -- AC, under his real name, and "Stanford Wong" and other guys who were respected wound up being hired as "expert witnesses" for a casino versus a card counter in a big court case. I'm sure that alienated a lot of knowledgeable folks. The fact this happened has led to questions regarding who's in bed with whom as far as LVA "experts" go -- the questions regarding Dancer's loyalties (casinos or his clients?) didn't come from thin air.
Somewhere along the way, as LV boomed, the LVA expanded from its niche readership to an attempt to appeal to the 30 million Las Vegas visitors in an internet world. LVA became "the big time," but that required reaching out to the California rich kids and five-star restaurant crowd. The old readership became a semi-meaningless subset of the whole subscribership.
Which brings us to now. I'm a professional -- but in terms of useful info, the best stuff I've gotten in the last two years were the M free room code postings and a discount code for Alamo. Really useful, but not exactly a deluge. So, coincidentally, I pretty much stopped offering info myself.