Logout

Question of the Day - 07 May 2021

Q:

If a casino wants to change the hold percentage (presuming here to increase it, of course) on a slot machine or perhaps many or maybe all in a casino, are they required to get approval from the Nevada Gaming Commission? And along those lines, what of the myth (I presume here also) of an opening night when machines are supposedly looser and later tighten days later — can that be done? And is approval needed? And last, how is the hold actually changed anyway?

A:

After a program is approved (and a copy is kept) by Gaming Control, there is no need to use EEPROMs.  There may be a few around, but programs generally are burned on just plain (cheaper) ROMs.

Also whatever the game is (reel spinner, video poker, et.al.,) there are already several programs on the ROM with varying return percentages.  As an example, a poker machine may have 9/6, 9/5, 8/5 JOB among the games.  The slot dept chooses what game and denom it wants available for the player.  The game library chip (ROM) is rarely exchanged.

True, it would take a lot of time to change the return % on a group of machines, but it wouldn't involve the hardware.  The time would be in the paperwork that the Slot. Dept. would want, to record the machine results before/after making a new game configuration.

s an example of something I've observed several times: I was playing a machine in a Colorado casino, and the slot tech was activating the machine next to me. He accessed a menu that contained all the parameters you mentioned, INCLUDING payback percentage. The submenu contained six choices ranging from 90.3% to 97.1%. These were obviously available with the same EPROM chip, since he didn't fiddle with the innards of the machine--he only entered his choices on the menu.

I've seen something similar many times, though never with such close and detailed observation--this slot tech obviously didn't care what I saw. It makes sense that payback percentages can be altered this easily. There would be no reason for slot machine manufacturers to require their customers (the casinos) to perform a full lobotomy on the machines every time they wanted to modify the payback %.

As to why and how often they would make these changes--different question. But I maintain they can do so very easily.

My machines all have 2 Compact Flash cards one is the OS and the other is the game. On initial setup you select the payback along with other options and it is set. If you want to change the payback % you have to use a Clear card and it wipes everything from the computer and you start all over. This takes anywhere from 8 to 15min per machine.
My machines are WMS but IGT and others are pretty similar.

Most machines are not server based games.  Some may be SSGs (Server supported games), but that's not even the norm.  In an SSG, the program is downloaded onto a machine, and remains there until deleted or removed, much like a physical Eprom chip.  Each of the eproms have multiple game programs that can be changed, but the changes have to be documented, and if a total program change is made, the machine has to be recorded as a new machine in the slot database.  It is NOT common to change these programs out...too labor intensive.  Eproms have been replaced with other media (thumb drives, etc), but the functions are still the same.  Quit worrying about management shifting their game percentages on the fly...it can be done with the few SBGs out there, but the game has to be taken out of service first for (IIRC) 5 minutes, so it's not really worth the effort to do so with the documentation that is required.  Also, SBGs require more regulatory stuff.

 

 

 

 

Frank Legato is the author of the book How to Win Millions Playing Slot Machines! ... or Lose Trying, founding and contributing editor of Strictly Slots magazine, managing editor of Global Gaming Business, and contributing editor to Casino Player magazine.

He tells us, “In the case of single games, the hold is changed by switching out the EPROM chips."

EPROM stands for Erasable Programmable Read Only Memory. They're the microchips that determine the theoretical return of slot machines. They do this by setting the machine's winning combinations and defining the paytable -- in other words, which symbol combinations are winners and how much they pay. Slot-department managers/directors can change the hold percentage by physically replacing the EPROM chip. 

In the case of a server-based setup, with which slot managers can change a slot machine's hold percentage remotely via software, Legato says, "That's rare. The idea never took off. But yes, they can also change the program remotely.”

As for notifying regulators of any change in a slot machine's hold percentage, that's not required in Nevada. The Nevada Gaming Control Board’s Michael Lawton tells us, “Changes to a slot machine’s hold percentage do not require GCB approval. Any changes to the par percentage would have to be documented and maintained by the licensee.” 

A par sheet lists all the details of a slot machine's operation: the game's reels and paylines, minimum-maximum wagers, payback percentage and hit frequency, plays per jackpot, jackpot amount, plays per bonus, etc. The par sheet enumerates the payout percentage of the machine, ensuring that the slot manager knows its "par result."

Veteran gaming regulator Richard Schuetz tells us, “I'm not aware of any such direct communication [about a casino needing to inform regulators of a change to a slot machines hold percentage]. Any change to a slot hold needs to be recorded in the property's internal control documents, to which regulators have access. Also, monthly reports show the actual hold for different categories of machines. Any requirements that insist on advance notice [of a change] would be news to me.”

All of which means that, yes, if a casino wants to open with loose slots and then tighten them, it can be done, although it would involve a lot of leg work changing out all those EPROM chips. 

It's our understanding that in actual practice, the EPROM chips aren't changed very often. For any given casino, there is some optimal return, based on its customer base and profit stance. Wherever that is, a smart slot manager generally finds that point, then leaves the EPROMS set to that return.

 

No part of this answer may be reproduced or utilized in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, without the written permission of the publisher.

Have a question that hasn't been answered? Email us with your suggestion.

Missed a Question of the Day?
OR
Have a Question?
Tomorrow's Question
Has Clark County ever considered legalizing prostitution?

Comments

Log In to rate or comment.
  • Kevin C May-07-2021
    This is part of why I play mostly older machines
    In my observation as a former IT manager, nearly all newer slot machines are (or at least CAN be) server controlled. I've been in several casinos when the power blinked and have seen Linux boot screens on many if not most newer slots. If it is Linux-based, it can be and probably is networked.

  • Kevin Lewis May-07-2021
    I've observed differently
    As an example of something I've observed several times: I was playing a machine in a Colorado casino, and the slot tech was activating the machine next to me. He accessed a menu that contained all the parameters you mentioned, INCLUDING payback percentage. The submenu contained six choices ranging from 90.3% to 97.1%. These were obviously available with the same EPROM chip, since he didn't fiddle with the innards of the machine--he only entered his choices on the menu.
    
    I've seen something similar many times, though never with such close and detailed observation--this slot tech obviously didn't care what I saw. It makes sense that payback percentages can be altered this easily. There would be no reason for slot machine manufacturers to require their customers (the casinos) to perform a full lobotomy on the machines every time they wanted to modify the payback %.
    
    As to why and how often they would make these changes--different question. But I maintain they can do so very easily.

  • Kenneth Mytinger May-07-2021
    Ken
    After a program is approved (and a copy is kept) by Gaming Control, there is no need to use EEPROMs.  There may be a few around, but programs generally are burned on just plain (cheaper) ROMs.
    
    Also whatever the game is (reel spinner, video poker, et.al.,) there are already several programs on the ROM with varying return percentages.  As an example, a poker machine may have 9/6, 9/5, 8/5 JOB among the games.  The slot dept chooses what game and denom it wants available for the player.  The game library chip (ROM) is rarely exchanged.
    
    True, it would take a lot of time to change the return % on a group of machines, but it wouldn't involve the hardware.  The time would be in the paperwork that the Slot. Dept. would want, to record the machine results before/after making a new game configuration.

  • Rick Sanchez May-07-2021
    Like Kevin Said
    My machines all have 2 Compact Flash cards one is the OS and the other is the game. On initial setup you select the payback along with other options and it is set. If you want to change the payback % you have to use a Clear card and it wipes everything from the computer and you start all over. This takes anywhere from 8 to 15min per machine.
    My machines are WMS but IGT and others are pretty similar.

  • Jackie May-07-2021
    Just in case
    anyone is thinking of using Kevin's observation as a way to access the same menu and change the payback, know this, every machine is monitored for any attempt to access it.  Slot techs, guards collecting money, and jackpot payout people have to call in a slot's id numbers and reason for access before they do anything or all hell breaks lose.

  • Gregory May-07-2021
    Machine types
    There are different types of games out there.  Las Vegas uses class III slots games.  Some states require class II machines.  The difference is that one machine uses a RNG (random number generator), and the other is based on the game of bingo.  They both can be manipulated or programmed, but my understanding is that type II machines are programmed in such a way that they pay a from a pool of money that all players contribute to much like a lottery.  Also the operating system of the game is irrelevant.  There are hundreds of operating systems.  Every micro-controller requires an operating system to function.  Even a pocket calculator has an operating system we just don't get to see it.  There's nothing particularly special about a slot machine that runs Linux.

  • Dave_Miller_DJTB May-07-2021
    Network
    Seeing a Linux or Windows boot screen means nothing. 
    
    ALL slot machines are on the network. Even older machines with physical reels and no monitor have a monitor jack inside, and are on the network. 
    
    For several reasons:
    TITO and players club data. 
    Day end reporting. 
    Jackpot notification. 
    
    But that doesn’t mean that the pay tables can be changed remotely. I’m not saying they can’t, I’m just saying you can’t assume either way. 

  • David May-07-2021
    SBGs never took off
    I actually audit this stuff.  Most machines are not server based games.  Some may be SSGs (Server supported games), but that's not even the norm.  In an SSG, the program is downloaded onto a machine, and remains there until deleted or removed, much like a physical Eprom chip.  Each of the eproms have multiple game programs that can be changed, but the changes have to be documented, and if a total program change is made, the machine has to be recorded as a new machine in the slot database.  It is NOT common to change these programs out...too labor intensive.  Eproms have been replaced with other media (thumb drives, etc), but the functions are still the same.  Quit worrying about management shifting their game percentages on the fly...it can be done with the few SBGs out there, but the game has to be taken out of service first for (IIRC) 5 minutes, so it's not really worth the effort to do so with the documentation that is required.  Also, SBGs require more regulatory stuff.

  • Diane Crosby May-11-2021
    Slot programs
    To add to this question, are most slot programs set to change the percentages at various times of the day or days of the week? From playing experience, that feels like it happens.