Logout

Question of the Day - 19 January 2023

Q:

It was I guess you might say ... curious to me when I saw the tempest in a teapot over the QoD writer's misuse of "affect" and "effect" in the one about fireworks on New Year's Eve. Some commenters maintained that bad grammar, typos, misused words, and the like are a "chronic problem" with the Question of the Day and there's no excuse for it. Others defended the QOtD, claiming that the occasional error is trivial compared to the good information that usually shows up in the answers. As usual, LVA didn't respond. My question is, what is LVA's response to the criticism? 

 

A:

The median word count of our QoD answers is typically 300-350 and that's every day of the year, adding up to 120,000 or so words annually. It seems to us that the laws of probability would dictate that we'll get some wrong. And we readily admit that we do. 

However, as for our content suffering from chronic blunders, frankly, we find that to be greatly overstated. If that were accurate, the type of faultfinding that appeared in the comments about the New Year's Eve fireworks QoD would be much more frequent and emphatic. 

Truth be told, the corrections are somewhat more recurrent than is generally known; that's because they're behind the scenes. Several literate friends of QoD read our answers when they're posted, looking for everything from mistakes in arithmetic and lapses in logic to historical accuracy and text integrity. And they don't hesitate to contact us, privately, when the inevitable and inadvertent bloopers make it through. Of course, they do it to help us, so we always embrace input and feedback from the eagle eyes out there that pounce on our gaffes. And we always correct mistakes that they point out to us.

Anyone who'd like to participate in the process is welcome to contact us through the Submit a Question link. If we can amend missteps before they become public in the comments, rather than after, subsequent readers don't have to wonder what the critical comments are referring to. 

Our response to the criticism also involves the economics of Question of the Day.

If QoD were password-protected, like LVA, and readers had to pay for access, we could afford to have the answers proofread. But QoD is an entirely free feature on this website that, if we do say so ourselves, is completely interactive, always informative, and often entertaining to the extent that any lapse in correct usage can be forgiven -- or if not forgiven entirely, at least overlooked -- for the sake of function over form.

In other words, no one's shelling out their hard-earned spondulicks for QoD, so any sense of entitlement to something more or better than what we can produce under the circumstances is, in our opinion, misguided. If the misuse of "affect" and "effect" compromises the credibility of QoD for you, why read it?

Anyway, perhaps we should conduct a poll about this. The obvious questions would be: Are you fed up enough with our grammatical, orthographical, typographical, mathematical, idiosyncratical, and all the other atical and aphical boo-boos to pay for Question of the Day? Or are you content to get the content for nothing and to live with the incidental indecorous incorrectness? Or should we limit access to QoD to LVA subscribers only, rendering it another benefit of membership and, in the process, a more exclusive club? 

Wadda yiz say? Pay or no pay for Question of the Day? Survey or no survey on pay or no pay? 

 

No part of this answer may be reproduced or utilized in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, without the written permission of the publisher.

Have a question that hasn't been answered? Email us with your suggestion.

Missed a Question of the Day?
OR
Have a Question?
Tomorrow's Question
Has Clark County ever considered legalizing prostitution?

Comments

Log In to rate or comment.
  • David Miller Jan-19-2023
    Whining
     It seems that some people have nothing better to do than complain. All they do is whine and apparently are not happy unless they have ruined someone else's day. These very vocal troublemakers are, in actuality, a very small percentage of the population. I pay little attention to them, as you should. Whatever you decide to do, even if it is leaving things as they have been for years, I will continue to read and enjoy the answers, even if an "I" is not dotted or a "T" crossed. Some people are just sick in the head.

  • Jackie Jan-19-2023
    The Shakespearian retort
    Much ado about nothing

  • Kevin Lewis Jan-19-2023
    Not perfect, but better than most
    The grammar and spelling of 99% of the content that appears on the interblab is atrocious, much of it showing ignorance of or indifference to the basics of writing. LVA's quality is much better than most in that regard. Error-free? No. But I don't think anyone has the right to demand that.

  • jeaninemb Jan-19-2023
    Delivers the Message
    Nicely said LVA. I appreciate your QoD work and look forward to it each day. This isn’t a scholarly journal. It’s a very generous, in both knowledge and spirit, offering to the Las Vegas gambling community, and for that I’m a grateful reader.

  • Bob Jan-19-2023
    David Miller 
    What He Said!     

  • William Nye Jan-19-2023
    Like what I read
    I live in the Buffalo, NY area and truly enjoy the information shared.  Keep up the good work and I hope to get out there again soon.  So keep me informed!

  • thebeachbum Jan-19-2023
    QOD Still Rocks
    No whining here.  Forget a period?  I'll keep appreciating QOD and put in my own period.

  • Kevin C Jan-19-2023
    Please keep it free
    Very well stated response to the criticism. I try to overlook all but the most egregious errors, and those I try to report privately unless the perpetrator is a total jerk. I have yet to encounter "a total jerk" among the LVA correspondents. 
    For me, the QOD and Vegas News sections of the site are required daily reading, even though my wife and I have reduced the frequency of our Las Vegas trips. I like to remain informed about the town and the industry, and I find LVA's QOD and Vegas News to be the best free way to do that. In fact, so many coworkers asked me about what to do/not do in Las Vegas that I wrote a "first timer primer," based upon our experiences, that I gave to anyone who asked. Much of it is woefully outdated now but my first item in the "Before You Go" section has always been "subscribe to and thoroughly read the Las Vegas Advisor." You folks are doing great work and I, for one, am thankful.

  • Vegas Fan Jan-19-2023
    Poll
    Let's do one. And please let us know when results are ready.

  • CHUCK Jan-19-2023
    keep It free
    QOD has less mistakes than the daily newspaper which I pay for.  Keep it free

  • Dave_Miller_DJTB Jan-19-2023
    Guilty
    I’m guilty of posting errors that I see. But only factual errors. When it comes to typos, and other minor things, we’ve all done it.
    
    But frankly, I never considered sending an error notice through the submit a question portal. I would have thought that those don’t get looked at quickly enough to make a difference in something timely like the QoD.

  • Jan-19-2023
    Thank you!
    You have answered a few of my questions in the past and I have learned a lot from QOD. Like you said, "If you have a problem with it don't read it anymore." It's free! Keep it FREE! ....I Hope I didn't missspell anything! 

  • Sandra Ritter Jan-19-2023
    Anyone out there perfect?
    I agree with all of the positive comments. Actually I'm always impressed with the vocabulary used in QoD. I often learn new words. I had a summer job during college at an actuary's office. Upon leaving to go back to school I was given a gift: a HUGE eraser with the following printed on it: "I never make mistakes. I thought I did once, but I was wrong." I've never forgot that. Let he/she/they who's never erred cast the last stone.

  • Peter Jan-19-2023
    A Karen?
    I find the QoD very informative and well written.  No changes please.

  • Johnny Estrada Jan-19-2023
    Some people have nothing better to do
    People who complain about the minor errors can go kick rocks.

  • Tal2 Jan-19-2023
    No need for a poll
    Don’t understand why someone would complain about something that is free, informative, interesting, and worthwhile. Some people are never happy. Ignore them. 

  • asaidi Jan-19-2023
    You Get What You Pay For
    I think that people complaining about things they get for free is why things that used to be free aren't free anymore.  
    
    You can't find a parking space? Well, we can fix that as long as you pay for parking.  You can't find a good seat by the pool?  We'll reserve a great one for you if you pay for it.  

  • Diamonddog2801 Jan-19-2023
    Really?
    People complaining about a completely free, no obligation to enter web page? Get over it. 

  • Deke Castleman Jan-19-2023
    This in via email
    For what it's worth, I've always thought QoD is extremely well-written and I'm always amazed at the amount of research that goes into it on a daily basis.  At the price of "$FREE," it should be first on LVA's list of top ten Las Vegas values. What in the world is wrong with some people who will pick nits and criticize about nothing? Geesh! 

  • [email protected] Jan-19-2023
    refund
    Give 'em their money back and cancel their subscription.  With all the labor-saving devices available, too many peeps spend their time in criticism, not in anything productive.   UGH!

  • [email protected] Jan-19-2023
    Grammar
    I used to be much more of a stickler for grammar.  Then I began to read the now inactive World Wide Words.  They pointed out two important things to me.  First that English is a constantly evolving language and that usage changes over time (a good example is the gradual demise of irregular past tenses, which is becoming universal in recent years).  They also pointed out that many of our grammar "rules" came from 19th century grammarians trying to force Latin rules onto English, even though most English words do not originate from Latin.  So the rule I follow now is can I understand what the writer is saying.  If so, the grammar is fine!

  • Randall Ward Jan-19-2023
    errors 
    I've spotted a couple but nothing big, and the total amount of information overwhelms any error.  

  • Texas Transplant Jan-19-2023
    Complainers need to get a life!
    QoD is fantastic.  I read it for content, and apparently unlike some readers, I AM NOT ANAL-RETENTIVE.  I don't look for typo's.
    
    I suggest that if an occasional misspelling / misuse of a word bothers someone, they need to go elsewhere.  I have been an LVA member for over 15 years, and usually read QoD and the rest of the new content at the LVA web site at least 4-5 times a week.  
    
    I have also had the opportunity to speak to LVA directly on several occasions and have also found them to personally be very accommodating.  I would like to give Kudos to everyone at LVA.  Keep up the great work. I know its not easy, but you ALL do a great job of presenting accurate, timely information...everyday.  
    
    

  • The Dr Jan-19-2023
    Karens
    :)
    Overall consenses is to ignore these types of people.  Don't waste your time on this in a poll.  Continue to provide the excellent information we all have come to look forward to.

  • bchell Jan-19-2023
    kudos
    If you get demoted for errors, you should get extra credit for vocabulary building words like spondulicks!  ...now does that comma belong after errors in the previous sentence?
    

  • jeepbeer Jan-19-2023
    poll
    i think instead if you were to do a poll as to which section of the LVA is the best i bet the QOD would come out on or near the top.

  • Dorothy Kahhan Jan-19-2023
    The errors are minor compared to the overall content
    I tend to ignore the errors, as they don't detract from the article. Further, there is a lot of added value, especially so when the "experts" such as  Bob Dancer are brought in to answer certain types of questions. So I say, ignore the whiners and keep doing what you're doing. The vast majority of us appreciate your efforts.

  • Robert Byrne Jan-19-2023
    Got to agree
    I've got to agree with most of thee comments. QOD is great, can't say I've noticed many typos getting through the filter, although being English I don't agree with some of the spellings (I accept that some words are spelt differently on your side of the 'pond'). Some people seem to have too much time on their hands and go out of their way to criticise others. 
    Keep up the good work with QOD and keep it free.

  • Raymond Jessen Jan-19-2023
    Casino Model
    Perhaps you could sell question of the day to a Strip Casino.  Then we could be charged retort fees and get less in return and asked to thank them for the honor of giving them our money.

  • rokgpsman Jan-19-2023
    Don't dwell on the Zeroes
    My longtime manager used to say "When people have the opportunity to complain, whine or nitpick many of them will. It's the only way some folks can make themselves feel superior, consider it a negative personality trait". 
    

  • Michael Mendoza Jan-19-2023
    you are doing a fine job!!!!!
    So ignore those who are so petty...no one is perfect...even me :)

  • Jersey Jeff Jan-19-2023
    Trolls
    Don't listen to the internet trolls who have too much time on their hands.  I've been reading QOD for close to 20 years and it's never been an issue.

  • bchell Jan-19-2023
    QOD
    Can you explain the graphics to the left of the comments, why they are different and do they signify anything?
    

  • Dan McGlasson Jan-19-2023
    Value of a spondulicks please?
    QoDs are awesome.  Keep them coming and ignore the haters.  Now what I REALLY want to know is if a spondulicks is a new crypto currency that LVA is sponsoring.  Heck, I might invest!  I am sure I would make more than my usual trip to Vegas profits me!!!

  • Ray Jan-19-2023
    It's what you already know
    There are always people who complain...about anythinhg and everything. Pointing out an error is not necessarily complaining, especially when it's factual and correctable. However, calling the LVA QoD sloppy or careless due to minor grammatical errors shows us more about them than you. Considering the large number of people who read the QoD and the tiny number who complain, I think we already know what the answer to a poll would be.

  • Keith Crane Jan-19-2023
    Nobodies perfect
    No pay, no survey

  • melman Jan-19-2023
    Don't be so thin-skinned.
    Don't take every suggestion of a misspelling or grammatical error as "criticism" but rather just as a "hey here's something I happened to notice".  We know it's free, we're grateful for it.

  • Mark Nakel Jan-19-2023
    LVA
    Stay the coarse, I love the LVA for its fun content, and look forward to the Qotd.  People gott a quit crying' about every darn thing in the world. Keep up the good work.

  • Raymond Ray Jan-19-2023
    Grammar police
    Some people aren't happy unless they have something  to bitch about.... Dude, you need to get laid😂😂😂😂

  • PK Jan-19-2023
    Too many Karend
    This isn't a deposition.
    As long as the poster gets their point across that's all that matters.

  • 145tech Jan-19-2023
    Kevin Lewis
    Kevin said it best!  Keep up the great work; LOVE the QOD!

  • Jon Anderson Jan-19-2023
    errors
    haters gotta hate and nitpickers gotta pick...and life goes on... keep up the grate job lva...haha

  • Howard M Jan-19-2023
    Don't Sweat It!
    The number of positive comments here speak for themselves. While some of your QOD's are of little relevance to me (I'm not a poker player, for example), I look forward to your daily digest for valuable insight on our great city, its history, casinos, shows, food, special events, etc. KUTGW! (That's short for keep up the good work!)

  • Andyb Jan-19-2023
    MLK
    Content over Grammer and Spelling, a quote from MLK!!!

  • rodfan Jan-19-2023
    Q of the Day
    Agree, love the question of the day!  It’s the email I actually look forward to.  To anyone who has the time to complain about this free article, could I possibly interest you dusting or anything else of need tending to in my home?

  • Debra Grimes Jan-19-2023
    Tempest in a teapot
    Nothing to see here...move along. Yes, keep it free; no, do not survey.

  • Dnalorailed Jan-19-2023
    Editor
    Just hire an editor. Freelance/part-time. It’s their job to check copy.  But I resent the implication that we should just be “grateful” for the content. This site is indeed monetized in some way. Some of us frequent the site daily. Our visits benefit us and you. Spend a few extra bucks…

  • Robert Rose Jan-19-2023
    Perfection
    I love the QOD and the YouTube videos and the News of the Day and everything LVA has to offer!  And, I purposefully didn’t add commas because my message isn’t about punctuation or the perfection of my comment.  It’s about the perfection of LVA.  Keep up your amazingly great work!!!!

  • dblund Jan-19-2023
    ...
    Many of us have our particular little things that drive us crazy, and I've known others who are perhaps overly bothered by spelling and grammer issues.  For me, it is the self-righteous who insist on calling out the minor and inconsequential errors of others, and I struggle at times to keep from calling them out as rude, insensitive and ungrateful boors, and I have to remind myself that none of this is worth thinking about for more than a minute.  LVA, IMHO you should skip the poll, accept our thanks for providing this service, and don't sweat the small stuff.

  • [email protected] Jan-19-2023
    "Mr. AC"
    The man who did the Seven Star's Insider, was truly into "grammatically correct," like no one I have ever seen. Now that he died, I wonder who is going to take up his mantel? 

  • [email protected] Jan-19-2023
    "Mr. AC"
    The man who did the Seven Star's Insider, was truly into "grammatically correct," like no one I have ever seen. Now that he died, I wonder who is going to take up his mantel? 

  • Bud Ackley Jan-19-2023
    @Anthony Curtis
    I was the original "complainer" of the QoD's sloppiness in having excessive errors. A few days after my comment, these four errors appeared within just a couple of paragraphs of the 1/8/23 QoD.
    
    1
    "when Billy was 13 he went back to live with his mother, an alcoholic, who charged him $10 a week to live in the basement of her"
    
    2
    "blowing through all his (and that of his second wife, Susan) money"
    
    3 & 4
    "culminated in a conviction in a jury trail for for insider trading"
    
    Come on, Anthony. That's ridiculous. (I'm assuming you wrote today's answer, because there were no errors, among other reasons.) Your copy, Bob Dancer's copy and the rest of the LVA website never have these lapses. No single error matters, but when errors pile-up, as above, they damage the stature and prestige which LVA has earned over the years.
    
    Since you say that the QoD is by far the most widely read part of LVA, it behooves you to make sure that its writing is on a level with the rest of your site.

  • Roy Furukawa Jan-19-2023
    Free
    As for the people that complain often and loudly about trivial things like this, I will use one of the internet’s biggest mistakes in calling them… loosers.  :D

  • Diane Crosby Jan-23-2023
    English Ed. Major
    I am an English Ed. major and loyal reader of this column. It does not bother me too much when others make mistakes in grammar. Don't get me wrong. I notice. However, I won't spend my life correcting everyone who errs. It's not how I want to live. About the pay or no-pay, I prefer no-pay. We come to 12 days of conventions in early January. Lately, the membership books have not been available for pick-up until we are leaving. That's why I have quit subscribing. If you every start getting them ready by the first or second week in January, I will be back on board!