Logout

Question of the Day - 20 September 2018

Q:

Many casinos have monthly drawings for cars. If you won, but didn't want the vehicle, would you be ahead taking the vehicle and reselling it or settle for the lesser cash amount the casino offers in lieu of the car?

A:

As described in The Frugal Gambler, in late 1994, Jean Scott received three free nights at the Stardust and 500 tickets for a January 1995 drawing -- nine of ten tickets pulled received cash prizes from $500 to $1,000. The tenth, the first ticket drawn, won a car.

Jean had been sick in bed all that day, but since you had to be present to win, she dragged herself down to the casino. She didn't have much hope for the drawing, since hundreds of people were milling around and countless thousands of tickets jammed the drum.

But then, to her vast surprise, her ticket was drawn first and she won a 1995 Mercury Mystique. The car came with $3,000 in cash to help defray the taxes. 

Jean also had the choice of taking a cash buyout for $9,000. 

But Jean, being Jean, wanted to learn if it would be worth her while to take the car and sell it. She visited the dealer from which the Stardust bought the Mercury for the drawing and asked how much she could get for selling it back.

"The dealer gave us a price and we took it," Jean remembered when we asked her about it in pursuit of this answer. "After taxes, we won $10,200 by taking the car and the cash, then selling it back to the dealer, $1,200 more than if we'd taken the cash. And we would do it the same way today!!" 

We suppose you could try to sell your car privately, perhaps on Craig's List or the like. You'd probably come out ahead in the end, but getting there might take awhile and turn into a hassle, especially if it's a much more expensive car than Mercury Mystiques were in the mid-1990s. For our part, we'd probably do it the way Jean and Brad did: Turn right around and sell it back to the dealer.  

 

No part of this answer may be reproduced or utilized in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, without the written permission of the publisher.

Have a question that hasn't been answered? Email us with your suggestion.

Missed a Question of the Day?
OR
Have a Question?
Tomorrow's Question
Has Clark County ever considered legalizing prostitution?

Comments

Log In to rate or comment.
  • Reno Faoro Sep-20-2018
    a car ?
    LVA was very nice answering this query. BUT,  how many people out of the million readers has this happened  to ?????? perhaps, 2- the questioner and jean scott.  ty,tyvm

  • Fumb Duck Sep-20-2018
    Car Drawing
    Actually, I thought the QOD was quite appropriate. I have participated similar drawings and often pondered what to do if I won the car.  Now all I have to do is get really, really lucky.

  • Gator Girl Sep-20-2018
    Location
    It would probably make a difference if you're a tourist or a local.  If you live in the area you'll have plenty of time to make up your mind and conduct the transaction.  But if you have a plane to catch in a day or two, you might want to just take the money and be done with it.