Logout

Question of the Day - 04 December 2022

Q:

Could you do a QoD about craps when you played against players rather than the casino?

A:

Happy to.

Casino or bank craps is a fairly recent phenomenon that dates back to the early 20th century, when dice-maker John H. Winn, widely considered the "Father of Modern Craps," changed the traditional game in a number of ways.

First, he introduced the crap bank, wherein the players, instead of betting against one another, bet against the house; Winn collected a half-percent commission on each bet placed on the games that he booked. He also invented the don't-pass line. Allowing players to bet against the shooter had the potential to double the action, as well as cut down, to a certain extent, on the chances of being cheated with loaded dice. Other dice players quickly adopted Winn's innovations and additional refinements were implemented; by 1910 or so, bank craps had overtaken faro as the most popular casino game in the U.S. It was further popularized when casino gambling was legalized in Nevada. 

For the thousand of years prior to bank craps, however, dice players were pitted against one another, a tradition that came to be known as "street craps."

The Indian Vedic hymns dating back to 2000 B.C.E. contain numerous references to the people's chief amusements, chariot racing and dice throwing. A little later, the Greek gods shot dice to divvy up the universe: Poseidon won the oceans, Hades the afterlife, and Zeus the heavens (they were Zeus' dice). In those and every dice game up until bank craps, the players won and lost one another's money and property.

The rules, customs, and challenges of player-versus-player dice games changed according to the time periods and cultures, as the dice  game of hazard, the progenitor of craps, was brought to Corsica by the Muslims, who conquered the island in the eighth century; from there, it spread quickly through Italy, then to Spain, France, and England, and gripped Europe for 1,000 years. A version of it entered the U.S. via New Orleans in the early 1800s and was transformed again by Southern slaves into a form of "private" or early street craps. That game made its way up the Mississippi River and east and west from there.

Craps was the number-one game played by GIs during World War II. Early gambling writer John Scarne estimated that $300 million changed hands over gambling games every month during the war (which seems impossible, until you remember that at its peak, eight million men and women were overseas in the Army, joined by 3.4 million in the Navy). Scarne, a writer at the time for YANK magazine, also printed two million odds charts for servicemen to stick in their helmets. A famous cartoon of that time shows five GIs around a pair of dice with the caption, "I'm learning how to shoot in the Army." 

Today, street craps is similar the world over, which means that the basic game probably hasn't changed all that much in modern times. It's easy to play, since only two items are needed: a pair of dice and a flat surface with a backstop. The players themselves oversee the action, so it's prudent to keep piles of coins or tokens separate and distribute winnings fairly to avoid accusations that might lead to violence.

Street craps starts with the players rolling the dice to determine the first shooter, according to local rules. 

The shooter is the first to bet and he (or she) can bet on or against himself; in most games, though, the shooter always bets on the pass. The rest of the players, combined, match the amount of the shooter's bet, but their money is on the "crap," or don't pass. In a word, they "fade" the shooter, meaning bet against. Whatever fraction of the shooter's total you bet, that's the fraction you'll win or lose. For example, if the shooter bets $20, four other players bet $5 each and if the shooter sevens out, the other players each get their bet back and another $5 out of the shooter's bet.

There's usually plenty of side action between players who want to bet on, well, just about anything, though the more common wagers are on the various rolls of the dice, including pass, crap, and the numbers. 

If the player rolls a seven, game over. If a point is rolled, the game proceeds just like in bank craps. Side betting can continue on each roll and those bets are settled as they're resolved, similar to side bets in bank craps. But the main pot isn't split up until the player repeats the point, in which case he wins all the other players' bets, or sevens out first, and loses his bet to his opponents. 

 

No part of this answer may be reproduced or utilized in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, without the written permission of the publisher.

Have a question that hasn't been answered? Email us with your suggestion.

Missed a Question of the Day?
OR
Have a Question?
Tomorrow's Question
Where did casino shills work in the '70s and '80s and how much did they earn?

Comments

Log In to rate or comment.
  • Stewart Ethier Dec-04-2022
    hazard
    To elaborate on your paragraph that mentions hazard, the game of hazard was played with three dice at the time of the Crusades.  The rules of the game can be inferred from Bodel's play "Le jeu de Saint Nicolas" (c. 1200).  See Kavanagh's "Dice, Cards, Wheels:  A Different History of French Culture" (2005).  Sometime during the 12th or 13th century, hazard evolved into a game played with two dice.  Two-dice hazard played a role in one of Chaucer's Canterbury Tales (14th century).  Its rules were described in detail by Charles Cotton in 1674 and in many 18th and 19th century works.
    
    

  • Stewart Ethier Dec-04-2022
    hazard, cont.
    There are two versions of two-dice hazard, English and French. We describe the English version first. The two players are called the caster and the setter. First, the caster calls out a number, known as the main, equal to 5, 6 , 7, 8, or 9, at his discretion. Then the caster rolls the dice. If he rolls a number that nicks the main, the caster wins. By definition, every number nicks itself, 5 and 9 are nicked by only themselves, 6 and 8 are nicked also by 12, and 7 is nicked also by 11.  The caster loses if he rolls crabs, that is, any of the numbers 2, 3, 11, or 12 that does not nick the main.  Any other number, of which there are six, becomes the chance. In that case, the caster continues to roll the dice until the chance or the main appears. If the chance appears first, the caster wins the amount of his bet from the setter. If the main appears first, the caster loses the amount of his bet to the setter. 
    

  • Stewart Ethier Dec-04-2022
    hazard, final
    In the French version of hazard, instead of calling the main, the caster rolls the dice until he obtains a number between 5 and 9 inclusive. This becomes the main, and the game proceeds as in the English version. Another distinction is that the players bet against each other in the English game, while they bet against the house in the French game.  It is clear how craps was derived from the English version of hazard. The caster simply calls the main of 7 every time.  This choice gives the setter his smallest advantage.  Thus, craps is a simplification of English hazard that first appeared during the 19th century.

  • Michael Mendoza Dec-04-2022
    5 dollar craps at el cortez
    not exactly oh topic, but about a month of so Andrew mentioned 5 dollar craps at the El Cortez. I was there a couple of weeks ago and it was 10 bucks on a Tuesday afternoon :(
    any 5 dollar craps tables anywhere?
    

  • Anthony Curtis Dec-04-2022
    Ethier's Contribution
    For those who don't know, Stewart Ethier is likely the world's foremost expert on the history and mathematics of craps (as well as baccarat and other games). You can take his information to the bank. I hope I haven't embarrassed him with this disclosure, as it's contributions like this from him and others that help make QoD what it is. Also, the movie The Big Town, starring Matt Dillon and Diane Lane, provides an excellent depiction of street craps. When I saw it, I stayed for the credits to see who the consultant was. It was Edwin Silberstang, who wrote Playboy's Guide to Casino Gambling and several other good gambling books.

  • Anthony Curtis Dec-04-2022
    $5 Craps
    You're referring to a comment made in one of our YouTube videos. I think Andrew was mistaken about the El Cortez. Ellis Island deals $5 craps and has 10X odds. Downtown Grand may also deal a $5 game.

  • R Geoffrey Dec-04-2022
    Abbot and Costello
    So their explanation of street craps is not entirely accurate?
    
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PvpmD6NXPfw
    
    They did a better version of it in a movie but this is what YouTube has.

  • Anthony Curtis Dec-05-2022
    R Geoffrey's Contribution
    This is awesome. As I said, it's contributions like this that help make QoD what it is.