10,000 dollars found and return, what would you do

Quote

Originally posted by: snidely333
Quote

Originally posted by: treegirl
I don't see the two instances comparable.


I don't either.


Its because they arent.
They're exactly the same thing. When you find money in Nevada, you have to surrender it to authorities. The player Jean Scott wrote about found $1510 and faced criminal charges for pocketing it and running.
Quote

Originally posted by: snidely333
If it was just $1000 cash laying on the street, I'd keep it.
I believe you.
Quote

Originally posted by: Chilcoot
They're exactly the same thing. When you find money in Nevada, you have to surrender it to authorities. The player Jean Scott wrote about found $1510 and faced criminal charges for pocketing it and running.
Quote

Originally posted by: snidely333
If it was just $1000 cash laying on the street, I'd keep it.
I believe you.

I don't believe a jury would convict someone of keeping $1000 found on the street...if there was no way to identify the real owner. I think they would convict someone of printing and cashing someone else's TITO. They are not exactly the same....even if they have the same treatment in law. In the real world, normal people see the difference. One is stealing a TITO...that required the perp to press the button, take it from the machine and cash it out....the other is finding money on the street.

Quote

Originally posted by: alanleroy
I don't believe a jury would convict someone of keeping $1000 found on the street...if there was no way to identify the real owner. I think they would convict someone of printing and cashing someone else's TITO. They are not exactly the same....even if they have the same treatment in law. In the real world, normal people see the difference. One is stealing a TITO...that required the perp to press the button, take it from the machine and cash it out....the other is finding money on the street.
I agree that a DA would have a tough time convicting someone of keeping $1000 in cash found on the street.

Doesn't make it legal to keep it, however. Different questions.

It's dangeous business, breaking the law in the hopes that a jury might not find the crime that big of a deal. And good luck with the IRS, should one fail to report it.

Quote

Originally posted by: Chilcoot
Quote

Originally posted by: alanleroy
I don't believe a jury would convict someone of keeping $1000 found on the street...if there was no way to identify the real owner. I think they would convict someone of printing and cashing someone else's TITO. They are not exactly the same....even if they have the same treatment in law. In the real world, normal people see the difference. One is stealing a TITO...that required the perp to press the button, take it from the machine and cash it out....the other is finding money on the street.
I agree that a DA would have a tough time convicting someone of keeping $1000 in cash found on the street.

Doesn't make it legal to keep it, however. Different questions.

It's dangeous business, breaking the law in the hopes that a jury might not find the crime that big of a deal. And good luck with the IRS, should one fail to report it.


Yeah right. I'm sure you feel the same way about finding a penny in Nevada. Turn it in to a cop whydontcha. It's The Law you know...and The Law doesn't care if it's a penny or a pound. The problem here is that the Politicans have passed a law that the vast majority of people don't agree with, but it's so trivial and impacts so few people that it's not worth the effort to elect new bums to change it.
Quote

Originally posted by: BAGIANT
I was up in Canoga Park once and I had to make a phone call to see if she was home. These were the days before cell phones were even invented. Lying on the flat space of the phone booth was this wallet. I looked inside and there was absolutely no cash inside. It was a mans wallet. But all his ID's and credit cards were inside, and I didn't want to see him have to go to DMV to replace his license and have to call up all his CC companies to report a lost or stolen card.

Just so happened that he lived near me in Beverly Hills, so I called 411 to see if he was listed. Yeah, in those days you could actually call up information for free. So I got the number and tried to call. His sister answered the phone and I told her about the found wallet, and that it had no money inside, just his license and CC's. I told her that since I lived by her that I could come by and drop it off. She said that would be OK.

So I find the address and start heading up this winding driveway. One I got to the flat spot of the driveway, I honked my horn to let them know I had arrived. All of a sudden two HUGE Great Danes came charging at my car. Now I was used to Great Danes since my sister had raised them when I was growing up so I really wasn't afraid of them. But I quickly had a change of heart when these two dogs started attacking my car! I never had seen a vicious Great Dane before. These two looked like they had been trained to be attack dogs. Luckily I had my windows rolled up so they couldn't get near me. A few minutes later, the sister came outt of the house to collect the wallet from me. I gave her the wallet and started backing out of the driveway. But these dogs were determined to have a piece of me before I left their yard. They chased me halfway down the drive until the sister gave some sort of verbal command which made them reluctantly go back home. I just hate to think of what would have happened to me had I gotten out of the car and tried to make it to the back door.


So you go to all the trouble to call/locate/drive to the house to return a wallet,
and they can't even take the small effort to restrain their two dogs, which probably scratched the paint right off your car ???

This comes under the heading of "No Good Deed Goes Unpunished".


Rick
Chilcoot.... seriously !?!?!?
The whole question is preposterous.
If someone finds a large amount of $$$ in a wallet with I.D. then it behoves the finder to return it to the OWNER !
However, finding $$$ (in say an envelope) with no way to track the owner is another story.
First (and foremost) no one (including the state) knows I have found it. I would wait a few days to see if some story emerges as to someone losing the "correct" amount. If so I can probably track the owner.
However, under no circumstance, am I going to alert the authorities or announce I have found the $$$.

That would be tanamount to announcing: "I found $10,000 ... would the owner(s) please line up in a double line to come and collect it !

Simply turning it over to a security guard, bank, police, government ... it ain't gonna happen. How stupid do I look ?
Quote

Originally posted by: pearlguy
Simply turning it over to a security guard, bank, police, government ... it ain't gonna happen. How stupid do I look ?
I do not know how stupid you look. Wouldn't even hazard a guess.

But it does sound like you look exactly like the woman who found $1510 of Jean Scott's money, decided to keep it, and then, under threat of criminal prosecution, decided to give it back. You may enjoy reading about her here.
Quote

Originally posted by: alanleroy
Quote

Originally posted by: Chilcoot
Quote

Originally posted by: alanleroy
I don't believe a jury would convict someone of keeping $1000 found on the street...if there was no way to identify the real owner. I think they would convict someone of printing and cashing someone else's TITO. They are not exactly the same....even if they have the same treatment in law. In the real world, normal people see the difference. One is stealing a TITO...that required the perp to press the button, take it from the machine and cash it out....the other is finding money on the street.
I agree that a DA would have a tough time convicting someone of keeping $1000 in cash found on the street.

Doesn't make it legal to keep it, however. Different questions.

It's dangeous business, breaking the law in the hopes that a jury might not find the crime that big of a deal. And good luck with the IRS, should one fail to report it.


Yeah right. I'm sure you feel the same way about finding a penny in Nevada...
Excellent point. If laws are nonsensical when they involve just one cent, let's stop enforcing them when they involve thousands of dollars!

Already a LVA subscriber?
To continue reading, choose an option below:
Diamond Membership
$3 per month
Unlimited access to LVA website
Exclusive subscriber-only content
Limited Member Rewards Online
Join Now
or
Platinum Membership
$50 per year
Unlimited access to LVA website
Exclusive subscriber-only content
Exclusive Member Rewards Book
Join Now